Read vs Listen: Fourth Wing

Nine provinces, ten dragons, and a map in the front matter that readers turn back to mid-chapter.

Confidence 74%, which puts it in the leaning band. Bands run from close call at 50 to 64, through leaning at 65 to 79 and clear at 80 to 94, up to clear cut at 95 and above.

What this book actually is

A single academic year at a war college, told in the first person and the present tense by one character, Violet Sorrengail, from the day of conscription to roughly ten days before graduation. It is linear. There is no second timeline and there are no flashbacks in the main text. Bonus chapters from Xaden Riorson's point of view are appended at the end rather than woven through.

The load is not the plot, it is the furniture. A reader is asked to hold two kingdoms and nine provinces, four quadrants of the college, a magic system built on signets, relics and wards, three categories of antagonist, a cast of well over a dozen named riders and six named professors, and ten dragons whose names are spelled in a Gaelic-derived orthography. The book supports all of that with a map in the front matter and an in-world epigraph at the head of every chapter.

The case for reading it

The map first. It shows both kingdoms, the nine provinces and the mountain ranges, and the geography matters, because characters come from named provinces and missions go to named outposts. Readers turn back to it, which is why other people have redrawn it and published printable versions. Then the spellings. Tairneanach, Sgaeyl, Aotrom, Sliseag: these are not names you can reconstruct from hearing them, and a listener who wants to look something up or post about it is stuck. Then the epigraphs, one at the head of every chapter, attributed to invented sources such as The Dragon Rider's Codex and set apart from the narrative in print, where audio simply reads them out.

The case for listening to it

It is a much stronger case than the verdict suggests. This is a linear story with one narrator, in short colloquial sentences with a great deal of dialogue, running 528 pages across twenty-two hours, which is an unusually low words-per-hour density. There is nothing to hold in two places, nobody's perspective to lose and no prose you would want to stop on. If you take audiobooks at speed on a commute, this is close to the ideal shape. Rebecca Soler carries the whole main text, and Teddy Hamilton's Xaden chapters are absent from the standard print hardcover, so on that one point audio has content print does not.

The audiobook in detail

Recorded Books released it on 2 May 2023, the same day as print, at 22 hours 3 minutes, about 14 hours 42 minutes at one and a half times speed. Rebecca Soler reads the main text and Teddy Hamilton reads the Xaden chapters. This recording has changed since release, which is unusual: Audible's own listing instructs existing owners to re-download the title to listen to the extended version, confirming the bonus chapters were added after publication rather than shipping at launch. Two people who bought the same audiobook a year apart did not necessarily get the same file. Separately, GraphicAudio produced an entirely different abridged dramatisation with a cast of more than fifty performers, sound effects and cinematic music, issued in two parts, the first running 7 hours 52 minutes. That has no print equivalent at all.

Who should ignore this verdict

Anyone happy to keep a map open on a phone while they listen, because that removes the single biggest objection here. Anyone who already knows the world from Iron Flame or Onyx Storm and does not need to learn nine provinces from scratch. Anyone who wants the dramatised version, which is a different product and a different experience from either the novel or the standard recording. And anyone who reads romance for pace, where twenty-two hours of low-density prose is exactly what audio is for.

Related verdicts

Questions people ask