Read vs Listen: The Housemaid's Secret

Wendy Garrick spends most of this book looking like a victim, and one narrator now has to sell two very different lies at once.

Confidence 78%, which puts it in the leaning band. Bands run from close call at 50 to 64, through leaning at 65 to 79 and clear at 80 to 94, up to clear cut at 95 and above.

What this book actually is

The Housemaid's Secret is Freida McFadden's second instalment in the Housemaid series, published by Bookouture in February 2023 and continuing the story of Millie and the wealthy Garrick family from book one. It is a contemporary psychological thriller set in a Manhattan penthouse, with no invented vocabulary or unfamiliar geography to hold onto, just a domestic setting most readers will recognise instantly.

The book is narrated in first person, predominantly from Millie's point of view, with chapters that switch to a second first-person narrator, Wendy Garrick, the wife of the household. A later part of the book retells some of the earlier events from Wendy's perspective, recasting what looked like a straightforward victim narrative into something less certain. That is the book's central trick: Wendy reads at first like someone to feel sorry for, and the reveal depends on the reader or listener having trusted that impression.

The case for reading it

The strongest argument for Kindle here is structural. The book does not move in a single straight line: a later section goes back over earlier events from Wendy's point of view, effectively retelling part of the story once the reader already knows more than they did the first time round. That kind of re-presented timeline is the one place print has a real edge, since it is easy to flip back and check exactly what was said, and by whom, the first time. Nothing else about the book pushes towards reading. There is no dense prose to linger over, no cast of names to keep straight, and no typographic tricks on the page. It is one structural wrinkle in an otherwise fast, plain-spoken thriller.

The case for listening to it

Everything else about The Housemaid's Secret points to audio. It keeps book one's short, cliffhanger-chapter rhythm, the kind of pacing that rewards being carried along rather than studied, and with only two narrating voices there is nothing to lose track of even without visual chapter headers. The bigger case is the unreliable narration itself. Wendy's chapters are written to read as a victim's account before that impression gets recast, and how convincingly that first impression lands is partly a performance question: tone, pacing and the moments a narrator chooses to let a reader's guard down all shape how hard the later recast hits. A single narrator voicing two first-person leads (Millie and Wendy) also means the listening experience depends on vocal differentiation between them, and if that is handled well it can make the switch between perspectives feel more distinct than it might on the page.

The audiobook in detail

The unabridged audiobook is read by Lauryn Allman, who also narrated The Housemaid, and runs 9 hours 44 minutes, coming down to roughly 6 hours 29 minutes at 1.5x speed. It is a straightforward single-narrator production rather than a multi-voice or full-cast recording, so Allman carries both Millie and Wendy's chapters herself. No awards or particular industry recognition for this specific narration have been confirmed, and there is nothing on record to suggest the audiobook adds sound design, music or any other production element beyond the narration itself.

Who should ignore this verdict

Readers who found themselves flipping back through The Housemaid to double-check who said what, or who specifically enjoy tracking a retelling structure closely, may prefer Kindle for this one, since the later section that revisits earlier events from Wendy's point of view is easier to cross-reference on the page. Anyone who simply wants to keep the series moving at the pace book one set, and is not fussed about re-checking earlier chapters, is well served by the audiobook instead.

Related verdicts

Questions people ask