Either

The Secret History by Donna Tartt: audiobook vs book, which should you choose?

A murder is announced at the start, one narrator looks back on events, and Donna Tartt reads all 22 hours herself. The prose and the Greek quotations are better taken in slowly in print.

Read vs Listen·Verdict last reviewed 23 October 2026·5 min read

Short answer: for The Secret History audiobook vs book choice, we say either works (55% confidence, close call). Donna Tartt reads it solo, unabridged, in 22 hours 3 minutes (Penguin Audio, UK edition). It is close because one narrator and a 640-page print edition point to audio. The prose, which critics argue over, and a critic who found the reading monotonous point to print.

Confidence 55%, which puts it in the close call band. Bands run from close call at 50 to 64, through leaning at 65 to 79 and clear at 80 to 94, up to clear cut at 95 and above.

What this book actually is

The Secret History is Donna Tartt’s first novel, published by Knopf in the US on 5 September 1992. The UK Penguin paperback runs to 640 pages.

Richard Papen, looking back about eight years, tells how he joined a small, closed circle of classics students at his college and what followed. The two-page prologue announces a murder before the story starts, which is why it is often called an inverted detective story. It is set out as a Prologue, Book I, Book II and an Epilogue.

It is on Time’s list of the 100 best mystery and thriller books and was a Read With Jenna pick, and Penguin Australia puts sales at over 5 million copies. It has never been filmed: in January 2022 Tartt’s UK agency said the rights are not available.

The case for reading it

Start with the sentences. The Secret History is a novel people argue about at the level of the prose: Michiko Kakutani praised it as “supple” and “impeccably controlled”, while Natasha Walter found it “sugary, over-refined” and Prospect called it “notoriously dense”. Either way, it is writing that asks you to slow down, and reading in print lets you do that.

Then there is the Greek. Greek and Latin quotations run through the book, some in Greek script and many with an English rendering alongside, and the vocabulary of the classics room (the aorist, the optative, the Liddell and Scott lexicon) is part of the story’s world. In print you can see the Greek and study it or skip it as you like. How the audiobook deals with it, whether read aloud, translated or passed over, is not stated.

The case for listening to it

The structure is friendly to audio. There is one narrator, and the prologue tells you a murder is coming and who was responsible, so the 22 hours are spent finding out how and why. Kakutani called it “ferociously well-paced”.

The audiobook is read by the author: Donna Tartt reads every English recording we found. The only critic review we found, Lauren Rosewarne’s in The Conversation, was not won over, describing the reading as “monotonous”, with the voices “all muddled together” and “far too many audible tape pauses”. Listener reviews on Audible are split, and the UK edition is rated 4.3 from 4,230 ratings, as of October 2026.

The audiobook in detail

Penguin Audio’s UK edition came out on 28 August 2010. Penguin gives the length as 1,323 minutes, which is 22 hours 3 minutes, unabridged: 14 hours 42 minutes at 1.5x and about 11 hours 2 minutes at 2x. Audible UK shows 22 hours 4 minutes.

In the US the lead edition is Random House Audio’s 2023 release, at the same length, and a 2004 HarperAudio release also exists. All are read by Tartt; whether they are one recording is not confirmed. There is no cast, music or bonus material, and we found no abridged recording.

Who should ignore this verdict

Lean towards print if you want to slow down over sentences that critics argue about: Michiko Kakutani called them “supple” and “impeccably controlled”, Natasha Walter “sugary, over-refined”. Print also lets you see the Greek in its own script and study it or skip it.

Lean towards the audiobook if you love hearing authors read their own work and are happy to take Tartt’s pacing as part of the experience, or if you already know the book and want to revisit it on long walks, where the Greek matters less the second time. Readers who stall on dense prose in print may find that hearing it read helps them through the slower stretches.

Try a sample first. The only critic review of the reading we found, Lauren Rosewarne’s in The Conversation, called it “monotonous”, and listener reviews on Audible are split, with the UK edition rated 4.3 from 4,230 ratings, as of October 2026.

Read differently from most people? The app, coming soon, will let you switch off any of the thirteen checks. Get notified →

Related verdicts

Different verdict

Whistler

Another novelist reads her own novel, and the verdict is to read it in print.

Different verdict

Circe

This book is also built on Greek myth, and the verdict is to read it in print.

Different verdict

A Little Life

This is another story about friends at college and what follows, and the verdict is to read it in print.

Start here

How we decide

The thirteen questions behind every verdict on this site.

Questions people ask