Alice in Wonderland audiobook vs book: which should you choose?

Short answer: for the Alice in Wonderland audiobook vs book choice, we say listen on Audible (65% confidence, leaning). Scarlett Johansson reads Audible Studios’ 2016 recording in 2 hours 44 minutes, unabridged, the lead listing on both Audible UK and Audible US. The one criterion that applies is a single narrator telling a story from one viewpoint, and nothing confirmed points to print.

Confidence 65%, which puts it in the leaning band. Bands run from close call at 50 to 64, through leaning at 65 to 79 and clear at 80 to 94, up to clear cut at 95 and above.

What this book actually is

Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, usually shortened to Alice in Wonderland, is Lewis Carroll’s 1865 children’s novel, published by Macmillan with 42 wood-engraved illustrations by John Tenniel. The first print run was withdrawn because Tenniel objected to the printing quality, and only 22 of those copies are known. It grew out of a manuscript Carroll gave Alice Liddell in 1864, “Alice’s Adventures Under Ground”, about half the length; the British Library holds it. Wikipedia calls the book an example of “literary nonsense”, notes it has never been out of print and counts translations into 174 languages. A sequel, Through the Looking-Glass, followed.

Alice, bored by a book “without pictures or conversations”, follows a hurried rabbit underground into a world of strange characters, including the White Rabbit, the Mad Hatter, the Cheshire Cat and the Queen of Hearts, across 12 short chapters. Several of its poems parody verses Victorian children learned by heart, from “How Doth the Little Crocodile” to “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Bat”. Pan Macmillan files its 2015 paperback, 208 pages with Tenniel’s illustrations, for ages 7 to 11, with a quiz, wordsearch and glossary; Waterstones shelves it under Children’s and Teenage. It sits with the classics here because no children’s shelf exists yet.

The case for reading it

The book argues for its own illustrations in its first paragraph, when Alice peeps at her sister’s book and asks what use a book is “without pictures or conversations”. The Macmillan paperback carries Tenniel’s black line illustrations, which Wikipedia calls “the definitive depiction of the characters”; the audiobook has none, and no Audible page mentions a PDF. The Mouse’s “long and sad tale” is printed as a tapering, winding column in the shape of a tail. It is concrete poetry from a century before the term existed, and the joke only works if you can see what Alice is looking at. “DRINK ME” is set in capitals on the label, and rows of asterisks mark the scene breaks in chapters I and V.

The puns are the subtler case. Most of them are homophones, tale and tail, not and knot, Tortoise and taught us, Reeling and Writhing, so a listener hears the joke. What the listener does not get is the two spellings side by side in print, which is where much of the nonsense comes from. At 208 pages, the Kindle edition can also be read in an evening.

The case for listening to it

It is short and funny, and one storyteller tells it directly to the reader. The same features led to a Listen verdict for Matilda and The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. Scarlett Johansson reads the whole book in 2 hours 44 minutes, about 1 hour 22 minutes at 2x, and Audible’s summary promises distinct voices for the White Rabbit, Mad Hatter, Cheshire Cat and Queen of Hearts. Listeners on Audible UK: “loved her voices for each of the characters”; “such a vibrant narration”.

Jodie Comer’s 2021 reading of the same text runs 3 hours 28 minutes and has more UK ratings than Johansson’s (2,212 to 957), with listeners praising “all the different accents and songs”; Miriam Margolyes is “excellent” on voices too. Whether any of them sings the songs is not confirmed. No critic has reviewed any of the three, and no award was found, which is why the check for praised narration does not apply.

The audiobook in detail

Scarlett Johansson’s reading, for Audible Studios, carries a 2015 copyright line and a 23 February 2016 release date, runs 2 hours 44 minutes unabridged and leads both Audible UK and Audible US for “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland” and for “Alice in Wonderland”. At 1.5x it takes about 1 hour 49 minutes. Jodie Comer (Audible Studios, 19 January 2021, 3h 28m) and Miriam Margolyes (Bolinda, 2010, 3h 22m) read the same text; Comer is about 27 per cent longer than Johansson, which gives a sense of the pacing. Naxos sells an unabridged multi-cast reading with David Horovitch and Jo Wyatt (2h 59m), and the BBC Radio 4 full-cast dramatisation (2h 50m, music and sound effects) is labelled Unabridged on Audible but is an adaptation.

Five listings bundle Alice with Through the Looking-Glass, including Katie Leung’s Penguin Classics edition (8h 47m, with Hugh Haughton’s introduction, which one listener called “torture”). Gemma Arterton (1h 2m) and William Rushton (1h 46m) read abridged versions. No Stephen Fry or Jim Broadbent recording appears on either store. No edition mentions the illustrations or a PDF. New recordings keep appearing: Lucy Scott joined Audible US in June 2026 and an AI-voice edition was added on Audible UK in August 2026.

Who should ignore this verdict

Anyone who wants Tenniel’s illustrations should read it. The Macmillan paperback carries his black line drawings, the audiobook has none, and no Audible page mentions a PDF. The Mouse’s tale printed in the shape of a tail and “DRINK ME” in capitals on the bottle are also only in print.

Anyone who enjoys the puns as written should read it too. Most are homophones that a listener hears, but the two spellings side by side only show in print. Anyone meeting Alice for the first time should see the pictures first.

Read differently from most people? The app, coming soon, will let you switch off any of the thirteen checks. Get notified →

Related verdicts

Same verdict

Matilda

A children’s classic read by a famous actor, where our verdict is to listen despite Quentin Blake’s drawings.

Opposite verdict

The Hobbit

Another children’s classic, with an audiobook read by Andy Serkis, where our verdict is to read it.

The Nutcracker and the Mouse KingE.T.A. HoffmannOpposite verdict

The Nutcracker and the Mouse King

A strange children’s fairy tale written as if told aloud, where our verdict is to read it.

Start here

How we decide

The thirteen questions behind every verdict on this site.

Questions people ask