Someone Else's Shoes audiobook vs book: which should you choose?

Short answer: for the Someone Else's Shoes audiobook vs book choice, we say listen on Audible (65% confidence, leaning). Daisy Ridley reads it on her own for Penguin Audio, 12 hours 22 minutes, unabridged, with no full cast. Library Journal and BookPage praised her narration and the print edition runs to 432 pages, and nothing confirmed points to print.

Confidence 65%, which puts it in the leaning band. Bands run from close call at 50 to 64, through leaning at 65 to 79 and clear at 80 to 94, up to clear cut at 95 and above.

What this book actually is

Someone Else's Shoes turns on a mix-up at the gym. Sam Kemp, worn down by a struggling marriage and a job she is about to lose, accidentally picks up a bag belonging to Nisha Cantor, a wealthy woman whose husband has just frozen her out of their life without warning. Inside the bag is a pair of designer shoes. Putting them on starts to change how Sam deals with her own crisis. The novel alternates between the two women's perspectives. On paper, one life is very comfortable and the other precarious, but their circumstances turn out to have more in common than either expects.

It is a contemporary, London-set novel, published in 2023, and it stays in a fairly conventional linear timeline throughout. The pleasure of it comes from the characters rather than the plot. Reviewers describe the side characters as fully formed and charmingly funny. The workplace and marital politics are played for both comedy and real sting. The two women's voices are meant to sound different because their lives are so different.

The case for reading it

There is not a strong structural case for it. The story runs in a straight line, there are only two points of view to hold rather than a sprawling cast, and the prose is accessible and dialogue-heavy rather than the kind of writing that rewards lingering on a sentence. None of the usual reasons to put a book on Kindle apply here: there are no jumping timelines, no crowd of names and no deliberate use of layout. If there is a personal reason to read it instead, it is pacing: some readers found the middle section slow, and a physical or e-book copy makes it easier to skim ahead through a lull than an audiobook does.

The case for listening to it

The case for audio is about the performance, not the plot. Reviewers keep mentioning how good Daisy Ridley is at making Sam and Nisha sound like two distinct people, rather than one narrator doing two accents on top of the same voice. One Goodreads reviewer called her "one of my favorite narrators" and said flatly "she killed it," and others specifically steer people towards the audio version over the printed book. That kind of praise is usually about skill rather than novelty. It means the recording adds something that reading the book yourself does not: you hear the difference between the two women's inner voices instead of having to imagine it.

The audiobook in detail

Penguin Audio released the recording alongside the print edition in February 2023, running 12 hours 22 minutes, with Daisy Ridley as the sole narrator across both Sam's and Nisha's chapters. One listener independently clocked roughly 12.5 hours at 1.4x speed, which lines up closely with the official runtime. At a more typical 1.5x listening speed, that comes down to around 8 hours 15 minutes, a manageable few sittings for a book of this length. There is no full cast and no dramatisation. One performer reads the whole audiobook, so its strength rests entirely on how well she tells her two leads apart. By all available reader feedback, she does this convincingly.

Who should ignore this verdict

Anyone who finds a single narrator voicing two alternating protagonists genuinely hard to track, regardless of how well it is performed, should read this one instead. The same goes for anyone who wants to skim through a slower stretch of story at their own pace rather than sit through it in real time, which is easier to do in print. For most readers, though, what makes this book distinctive is Sam and Nisha's contrasting lives, and that is exactly what the audiobook performs best.

Read differently from most people? The app, coming soon, will let you switch off any of the thirteen checks. Get notified →

Related verdicts

Same shelf

Lessons in Chemistry

Another determined female lead written for the book-club audience, and one that we decided for print.

Same shelf

The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

A different dual-timeframe emotional drama, where a single narrator also gives a standout performance.

Same verdict

Fourth Wing

A fast, action-driven fantasy, very different from this slower, dialogue-led contemporary novel.

Same verdict

Me Before You

By the same author: Lou Clark’s story told in several voices, which has a Listen verdict.

Start here

How we decide

The thirteen questions behind every verdict on this site.

Questions people ask