Every verdict checked against the same thirteen questions. No paid placements.The free app is coming soon. Get early access →
Home › Series › Middle-earth
Series guide

Middle-earth books in order: which to read and which to listen to

The Hobbit and the three volumes of The Lord of the Rings, all read by Andy Serkis on Audible. Each book has its own read or listen verdict, in reading order.

Read vs Listen·First published 10 November 2026·Last edited 12 November 2026·4 min read

Short answer: The Hobbit is a read at 58% (a close call). The Fellowship of the Ring is a listen at 70% (leaning), The Two Towers is a read at 65% (leaning) because it interlaces separate groups, and The Return of the King edges to audio at 56%, a close call, on length. All four audiobooks run 75h 41m.

The series at a glance

#BookVerdictAudiobookNarratorPages
BookThe HobbitRead, 58%10h 24mAndy Serkis336
1The Fellowship of the RingListen, 70%22h 38mAndy Serkis423
2The Two TowersRead, 65%20h 47mAndy Serkis352
3The Return of the KingListen, 56%21h 52mAndy Serkis416
All four75h 41m

Lengths from the Audible UK listings for Andy Serkis’s recordings, checked 10 November 2026. The Hobbit is the HarperCollins paperback. The Lord of the Rings page counts are the first editions in Wikipedia.

Which recording?

Andy Serkis reads The Hobbit and all three volumes of The Lord of the Rings, unabridged, for HarperCollins. His Hobbit is from 2020 and the three Lord of the Rings volumes were released together on 16 September 2021. Those are the recordings we score. Rob Inglis also reads the books solo and unabridged. The BBC made full-cast radio dramatisations, and a Highbridge dramatisation is on Audible US only. Dramatisations are shorter and are never scored in place of the full text.

BookPerformance, Audible UKPerformance, Audible US
The Fellowship of the Ring4.91 from 10,2864.95 from 22,880
The Two Towers4.96 from 5,6194.97 from 13,907
The Return of the King4.93 from 2,9354.97 from 7,227

Performance ratings and counts as shown on Audible for Andy Serkis’s recordings on 10 November 2026. The rating for The Hobbit is on its own verdict page.

How long is the series?

BookAudiobookAt 1.5xAt 2x
The Hobbit10h 24m6h 56m5h 12m
The Fellowship of the Ring22h 38m15h 5m11h 19m
The Two Towers20h 47m13h 51m10h 24m
The Return of the King21h 52m14h 35m10h 56m
All four75h 41m50h 27m37h 51m

Lengths from the Audible UK listings for Andy Serkis’s recordings, checked 10 November 2026. Totals and speed times are calculated.

Other recordings

BookRob Inglis, solo, UK 2005BBC full-cast dramatisation, 2007
The Fellowship of the Ring19h 53m4h 35m
The Two Towers16h 36m4h 29m
The Return of the King17h 12m3h 10m

Lengths from Audible UK, checked 10 November 2026. The BBC versions are dramatisations of the full story, so they are far shorter.

Reading order

The Hobbit comes first because Tolkien wrote it earlier, and the Lord of the Rings follows it. Nothing we found says you must read The Hobbit first. The Lord of the Rings is one story published in three volumes, so read them in order.

  1. The Hobbit (1937)
  2. The Fellowship of the Ring (1954)
  3. The Two Towers (1954)
  4. The Return of the King (1955)

Separately, Letters from Father Christmas is a Tolkien book too, and our verdict for it is listen, 64%.

More epic fantasy series: A Song of Ice and Fire (Game of Thrones), every book in order with its verdict.

Questions people ask

What order should I read the Middle-earth books in?

The Hobbit first, then The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers and The Return of the King. Tolkien wrote The Hobbit earlier and the Lord of the Rings follows it (Wikipedia).

Who narrates the Middle-earth audiobooks?

Andy Serkis reads The Hobbit and all three volumes of The Lord of the Rings on Audible UK and US. Rob Inglis also has solo recordings of the books.

How long are the Middle-earth audiobooks in total?

All four of Andy Serkis’s recordings run 75 hours 41 minutes on Audible UK: about 50h 27m at 1.5x and 37h 51m at 2x (calculated).

Are the BBC and Highbridge versions the full books?

No. They are full-cast dramatisations and far shorter than the full-text readings, so we mention them but never score them.

Should I read or listen to the Middle-earth books?

The gap is small for every book. The Hobbit is a read, a close call. The Fellowship of the Ring is a listen at 70% (leaning), because its single thread centred on Frodo suits one narrator. The Two Towers is a read at 65% (leaning), because it interlaces separate groups read by one narrator. The Return of the King edges to audio at 56%, a close call, on length.

Related verdicts

How these verdicts were reached

Every book on this site is checked against the same thirteen questions, set in advance and applied identically to every title. They are based on research into what readers and listeners generally find easier to follow in each format, not on personal preference, and they are published in full so you can check the reasoning yourself. Verdicts are never paid for, sponsored or influenced by affiliate partners.

  • The criteria: read the thirteen questions in full.
  • What we checked: the Audible UK and US listings for each recording, Wikipedia for publication dates and page counts, Kirkus, and the live verdict for The Hobbit.
  • Last edited: 12 November 2026. Editions and narrators change, so verdicts are rechecked annually.