Every verdict checked against the same thirteen questions. No paid placements.The free app is coming soon. Get early access →
Home › Verdicts › Crime & thrillers › Brain Damage
Either

Brain Damage by Freida McFadden: audiobook vs book, which should you choose?

Charly McKenna, a dermatologist, survives being shot and has to rebuild her memory and her mobility. An even split between the formats.

Read vs Listen·First published 13 November 2026·Last edited 13 November 2026·5 min read
Brain Damage by Freida McFadden
The verdict
The same thirteen checks for every bookSix checks point to listening, such as a full cast or produced audio, the author reading their own memoir, or one narrator for a single viewpoint. Seven point to reading, such as jumping timelines, three or more viewpoints, or a story that depends on images or layout. Each check has a weight, and the weighted total sets the verdict. Verdicts are never paid for. The percentage rises with the gap between the two sides and with how much evidence there is, so a couple of small checks can’t make a book clear cut on their own: 50 to 64 is a close call, 65 to 79 is leaning, 80 to 94 is clear, and 95 or more is clear cut. See how we decide in full →

Either works

Either works for Brain Damage, so pick the format you enjoy. Charly tells her own story and Megan Tusing reads it alone, rated 4.59 on Audible UK, which suits listening. The chapters move between the days before Charly is shot and the months after, and in print those switches are easier to keep straight.

Audible listeners rate the narration 4.6 out of 5 (373 ratings)

  • Pick the audiobook if you want to stay close to Charly: she tells the story herself, and listeners rate Megan Tusing’s reading 4.59 on Audible UK.
  • Pick the book if you like to keep two timelines straight: the chapters move between before and after the shooting.
Definitely readDefinitely listen
52%
Either
Get it on Kindle384 pages (UK paperback) · about 6½ hours to readListen on Audible9h 15m, read by Megan Tusing

Affiliate links: we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you. It never changes a verdict.

Do you agree with this verdict?

We said either format works. One tap, no sign-up.

The audiobook at a glance

RecordingUK edition, our verdictUS edition
NarratorMegan TusingMegan Tusing
Length9 hours 15 minutes (9h 15m), unabridged9 hours 15 minutes (9h 15m), unabridged
At 1.5xabout 6h 10mabout 6h 10m
At 2xabout 4h 38mabout 4h 38m
Audio publisher and datePodium Audio, 16 August 2022Podium Audio, 16 August 2022
PrintPoisoned Pen Press paperback, 384 pagesSame book
Listener ratingPerformance 4.59 from 373 ratingsPerformance 4.70 from 6,544 ratings

Megan Tusing reads it on both Audible UK and US, with the same release date, so the UK listing is the one scored. The listings don’t say whether the two are the same recording.

Audible US lists it with Dead Med under “Prescription: Murder”. We found no PDF companion. Ratings checked 13 November 2026.

Lengths checked 13 November 2026. Speed times are calculated.

Brain Damage

Freida McFadden

Genre
Psychological thriller
Series
Standalone
First published
2016
Length
384 pages (UK paperback)
On audio
9 hrs 15 mins, Megan Tusing

Why we reached this verdict

Every book on this site is checked against the same thirteen questions. They are based on research into what most people find easier to follow in each format, not on whether the book is any good.

One check points to reading
✓
Jumping timelinesBookreporter’s Ray Palen: “The novel is set up with chapters that occur both before and after the shooting.” Kirkus also describes two timelines. In print each switch is easy to see.
One check points to listening
✓
Single point of view and narratorSuperSummary says it is “Narrated by the protagonist, Dr. Charlotte ‘Charly’ McKenna”, and Megan Tusing reads it alone. It is one person’s story, which suits one narrator.
Checked, not a factor here (11)
–
Three or more points of view, one narratorOne main point of view, so this check doesn’t apply.
–
Story depends on images or layoutNothing in the story depends on images or layout.
–
Many similar-sounding namesNothing we found says readers mix up the names.
–
Literary or dense proseKirkus says McFadden’s “writing talent makes it interesting and engaging”, not dense or literary.
–
Narration criticisedPerformance 4.59 from 373 ratings on Audible UK, and we found no criticism of the reading.
–
Maps, family trees or footnotesNothing we found mentions a map, family tree or footnotes, and no PDF comes with the audiobook.
–
Full cast or produced audioMegan Tusing reads it alone, so it isn’t a cast, music or sound design.
–
Read by the authorIt is a novel, so the author-reading check doesn’t apply.
–
Award-winning or praised narrationWe found no critic review of Megan Tusing’s reading.
–
Unfamiliar names or dialectNothing we found points to unfamiliar names, accents or dialect.
–
Long book384 pages in the UK paperback, under 400.
How the score adds up
Listening 7 points, reading 8

Charly telling her own story with one reader (7) gives listening 7 points, while the chapters before and after the shooting (8) give reading 8. That’s close to even at 52%, so either format works.

Every book gets the same thirteen checks, set in advance. Verdicts are never paid for or influenced by affiliate links. Last edited 13 November 2026, and rechecked every year as editions and narrators change. Read the checks in full · Is listening the same as reading? See what the research says.

The recording in detail

One narratorMulti-voiceFull castDramatised
Scored
Megan Tusing, Podium Audio, 2022, 9h 15m, unabridged
Critic review
No critic review of this recording found
Alternatives
None found: one recording on each store
What you miss
Nothing. There’s no map, glossary or special layout

What this book actually is

Brain Damage is a Freida McFadden thriller first self-published in 2016 (Kirkus); Poisoned Pen Press published a new paperback in 2026. It is “Narrated by the protagonist, Dr. Charlotte ‘Charly’ McKenna” (SuperSummary), a dermatologist who survives being shot.

Kirkus describes two timelines: “events leading up to the day Charlotte barely survives” and “the months afterward, when she struggles to reclaim her memory and her mobility.”

The case for reading it

The two timelines are the case for print. On the page you can see whether a chapter is before or after the shooting, and turn back to compare what Charly remembers with what happened.

At 384 pages in paperback it is a quick read; Kirkus says McFadden’s “writing talent makes it interesting and engaging”.

The case for listening to it

Charly tells her own story and Megan Tusing reads it alone, so the audiobook keeps you inside one person’s head as she tries to piece her memory back together.

Listeners rate the performance 4.59 on Audible UK and 4.70 on Audible US.

The audiobook in detail

Megan Tusing reads it alone, unabridged, in 9 hours 15 minutes. The scored UK listing is from Podium Audio, released on 16 August 2022, and Audible US lists the same narrator, length and date. No PDF comes with the audiobook.

Who should ignore this verdict

Neither format has a strong edge. Choose the audiobook for Charly’s voice and the strong listener ratings, or the page if you like to keep the timelines in view.

Get Brain Damage
Both editions, so you can go with the verdict or ignore it entirely.

Audiobook

  • Read by Megan Tusing
  • 9h 15m
  • Unabridged
Listen on Audible

Kindle

  • 384 pages (UK paperback)
  • Easy to flick back to an earlier chapter
  • About 6½ hours to read (our estimate)
Get the Kindle edition
Affiliate links. If you buy through one of these we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you, and with no influence on the verdict above.

Related verdicts

Questions people ask

Who narrates the Brain Damage audiobook?

Megan Tusing reads it alone.

How long is the Brain Damage audiobook?

9 hours 15 minutes, unabridged. That is about 6 hours 10 minutes at 1.5x and 4 hours 38 minutes at 2x (calculated).

Is the Brain Damage audiobook abridged?

No. It is unabridged.

Is Brain Damage a new book?

No. It was first self-published in 2016 (Kirkus), and Poisoned Pen Press published a new paperback in 2026.

Is Brain Damage part of a series?

It is a standalone. Audible US groups it with Dead Med under “Prescription: Murder”.

Should I read or listen to Brain Damage?

Either works. Charly tells her own story with one reader, which suits audio, but the chapters switch between before and after the shooting, which is easier to follow in print.

Spotted a mistake on this page? Tell us and we will fix it. Or tell us how the site could be better.

Deciding about a different book?

Search for it. If we've written it up, we'll take you to the verdict. If not, we'll add it to our list of books to check.

Brain DamageOur pick: either works · 52%
AudibleKindle