Every verdict checked against the same thirteen questions. No paid placements.The free app is coming soon. Get early access →
Home › Verdicts › Romance & rom-com › One Day
Listen

One Day by David Nicholls: audiobook vs book, which should you choose?

Emma and Dexter meet on their graduation night in 1988, and the book visits them on the same day, 15 July, every year for twenty years. It is a close call that edges to audio.

Read vs Listen·First published 12 November 2026·Last edited 12 November 2026·5 min read
One Day by David Nicholls
The verdict
The same thirteen checks for every bookSix checks point to listening, such as a full cast or produced audio, the author reading their own memoir, or one narrator for a single viewpoint. Seven point to reading, such as jumping timelines, three or more viewpoints, or a story that depends on images or layout. Each check has a weight, and the weighted total sets the verdict. Verdicts are never paid for. The percentage rises with the gap between the two sides and with how much evidence there is, so a couple of small checks can’t make a book clear cut on their own: 50 to 64 is a close call, 65 to 79 is leaning, 80 to 94 is clear, and 95 or more is clear cut. See how we decide in full →

Listen on Audible

Listen to One Day, though it is a close call. The book visits Emma and Dexter on the same date each year for twenty years, moving steadily forward, and nothing we checked points to print. Annabel Scholey reads the newest recording, released in 2024. With so few points in play, either format will serve this love story well.

Definitely readDefinitely listen
56%
Listen
Listen on AudibleOur pick · 14h 18m, read by Annabel ScholeyKindle edition464 pages (UK paperback) · about 7½ hours to read

Affiliate links: we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you. It never changes a verdict.

Do you agree with this verdict?

We said listen on Audible. One tap, no sign-up.

The audiobook at a glance

RecordingAnnabel Scholey, our verdictAnna Bentinck, 2009
NarratorAnnabel ScholeyAnna Bentinck
Length14 hours 18 minutes (14h 18m), unabridged16 hours 25 minutes (16h 25m), unabridged
At 1.5xabout 9h 32mabout 10h 57m
At 2xabout 7h 9mabout 8h 13m
Audio publisher and dateW. F. Howes, 11 July 2024W. F. Howes, 2009 (Audible UK)
PrintHodder paperback, 464 pages; first published 11 June 2009Same book
Listener ratingPerformance 4.88 from 40 ratings (UK)Performance 4.48 from 1,858 ratings (UK)

Two unabridged recordings are on Audible UK and US. Annabel Scholey’s, released on 11 July 2024 on both stores, is the newer, so it is the one scored. Anna Bentinck’s 2009 recording is still on sale.

A 2-hour 15-minute abridged reading by Julian Rhind-Tutt also exists and is not scored. Ratings checked 12 November 2026. Prices change often, so check the store before you buy.

Lengths checked 12 November 2026. Speed times are calculated.

One Day

David Nicholls

Genre
Romance
First published
2009
Length
464 pages (UK paperback)
On audio
14 hrs 18 mins, Annabel Scholey
On screen
One Day (Netflix, 2024)

Why we reached this verdict

Every book on this site is checked against the same thirteen questions. They are based on research into what most people find easier to follow in each format, not on whether the book is any good.

One check points to listening
✓
Long bookThe UK paperback has 464 pages, and the 14-hour audiobook lets you take it in on walks and commutes.
Checked, not a factor here (12)
–
Full cast or produced audioAnnabel Scholey reads it alone, so it isn’t a cast, music or sound design.
–
Read by the authorIt is a novel, so the author-reading check doesn’t apply.
–
Single point of view and narratorOne narrator reads it, but the story follows two leads, Emma and Dexter.
–
Award-winning or praised narrationWe found no award and no named review of Annabel Scholey’s reading.
–
Unfamiliar names or dialectNothing we found comments on accents or dialect.
–
Jumping timelinesThe story moves forward one year at a time, without jumping back and forth.
–
Three or more points of view, one narratorThe story follows two leads, so the three-viewpoint check doesn’t apply.
–
Story depends on images or layoutNothing in the story depends on images or layout.
–
Many similar-sounding namesNothing we found says readers mix up the names.
–
Literary or dense proseNothing we found calls the prose dense or literary.
–
Narration criticisedPerformance 4.88 from 40 ratings on Audible UK, and no critic criticises the reading.
–
Maps, family trees or footnotesNothing we found mentions a map, family tree or footnotes, and no PDF comes with the audiobook.
How the score adds up
Listening 3 points, reading 0

The book’s length (3) gives listening 3 points. That puts it at 56%, a close call that edges to audio. Nothing scores for reading, but a clear-cut verdict needs more than 3 points on one side.

Every book gets the same thirteen checks, set in advance. Verdicts are never paid for or influenced by affiliate links. Last edited 12 November 2026, and rechecked every year as editions and narrators change. Read the checks in full · Is listening the same as reading? See what the research says.

The recording in detail

One narratorMulti-voiceFull castDramatised
Scored
Annabel Scholey, W. F. Howes, 2024, 14h 18m, unabridged
Critic review
No critic review of this recording found
Alternatives
Anna Bentinck, W. F. Howes, 2009 (16h 25m)
What you miss
Nothing. There’s no map, family tree or special layout

What this book actually is

One Day is David Nicholls’s 2009 novel. Emma and Dexter meet on their graduation night in 1988, and each chapter visits them on 15 July of the following years, for twenty years. “The other 364 days of each year are skipped” (Wikipedia).

Netflix adapted it as a series in 2024.

The case for reading it

None of our reading checks applies here. The story moves forward a year at a time, it follows two leads, and nothing we found calls the prose dense or points to anything printed that audio would lose.

Read it if you like to flick back through the years, or simply prefer a love story on the page.

The case for listening to it

Annabel Scholey reads the newest recording, released in July 2024, and listeners on Audible UK rate her performance 4.88, though from only 40 ratings so far. We found no critic review of it yet.

At 14 hours, the audiobook is a comfortable listen over a week or two of commutes, and the year-by-year structure gives natural places to stop.

The audiobook in detail

Annabel Scholey reads it alone, unabridged. Her recording is from W. F. Howes, released on 11 July 2024 on both Audible UK and US, and runs 14 hours 18 minutes.

Anna Bentinck’s earlier unabridged recording (2009 on Audible UK, 2010 on Audible US) is still on sale and has many more ratings. No PDF comes with either.

Who should ignore this verdict

This is close to even. If you prefer reading romance, nothing here makes the audiobook the better choice; if you want a story to listen to on the commute, it works well by ear.

Get One Day
Both editions, so you can go with the verdict or ignore it entirely.
Our pick

Audiobook

  • Read by Annabel Scholey
  • 14h 18m
  • Unabridged
Listen on Audible

Kindle

  • 464 pages (UK paperback)
  • Flick back through the years
  • About 7½ hours to read (our estimate)
Get the Kindle edition
Affiliate links. If you buy through one of these we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you, and with no influence on the verdict above.

Related verdicts

Questions people ask

Who narrates the One Day audiobook?

Annabel Scholey reads the 2024 recording. An earlier recording is read by Anna Bentinck. Both are on Audible UK and US.

How long is the One Day audiobook?

14 hours 18 minutes, unabridged, for Annabel Scholey’s recording. That is about 9 hours 32 minutes at 1.5x and 7 hours 9 minutes at 2x (calculated).

Is the One Day audiobook abridged?

Scholey’s and Bentinck’s recordings are unabridged. A 2-hour 15-minute abridged reading by Julian Rhind-Tutt also exists.

What is the structure of One Day?

Each chapter visits Emma and Dexter on 15 July, one year at a time, for twenty years (Wikipedia).

Is One Day a TV series?

Yes. Netflix adapted it in 2024.

Should I read or listen to One Day?

Listen, a close call. Nothing we checked points to print, and the book’s length suits audio, but only a few points are in play, so either format works. Read it if you prefer romance on the page.

Spotted a mistake on this page? Tell us and we will fix it. Or tell us how the site could be better.

Deciding about a different book?

Search for it. If we've written it up, we'll take you to the verdict. If not, we'll add it to our list of books to check.

One DayOur pick: listen · 56%
KindleListen on Audible